Our Reviews
Thinking of giving us a try? Check out these reviews from our many happy customers.
Jeff A.
1685237084
Excellent service food and cocktails. And the location is a bonus. A must in this area.
Julie W.
1685149585
Outstanding restaurant, environment, service and most importantly- delicious well prepared food. Will come again when I vacation here again.
Carmella M.
1685063906
Celebrating a friend birthday tonight it was her first time at Magnolia. The food was amazing. Beautiful presentation my friend said it was the best salmon she ever tasted. Service was excellent. And it was nice that Keith the GM came over to say hello.
Leslie Q.
1684966826
Really nice out on the patio looking out at the ocean. Fans were blowing which helps with the heat and flies. Service was outstanding and off season $65 dollar special for 2 with 4 choices plus desert!
Kathleen G.
1684673059
They take reservations 😀. Valet parking. Adorable and designed well. The restaurant is completely outside. (Covered). Our waitress was terrific and well versed in knowing everything about the menu and bar. She didn’t rush us through. The menu is pricey but the food was delicious. The raw tuna was the best I’ve ever eaten. We also ordered ceviche which was very good. My main dish was the grouper which was Catch of the day. It was perfectly prepared and presented. After dinner we walked down the patio and sat on the Adirondack chairs to enjoy the beautiful view of the bay.
Victor L.
1684099070
Elegant dining experience . Great food and wonderful atmosphere and service
David S
1683939146
Brian is the best bartender ever!
Ally A.
1683765415
One of the best places I’ve dined at by far. The food, drinks, customer service, and atmosphere was amazing. Our waitress was so friendly and the manager Sam even stopped by to ask how everything was. Definitely recommend the octopus appetizer. Will be returning when in Florida again!
April P.
1683651849
This is by far our favorite restaurant! The food, service and the atmosphere are all amazing! We can't say enough about this place and tell anyone that will listen about it!
Dave W.
1683521907
We had reservations for our 20th anniversary and we were not disappointed. Our entire experience was outstanding from the atmosphere to the food. My...
Alyssa P.
1683428687
Venture this way due to the food looking like the most outstanding spot on the island and I wasn't disappointed!I'm not always in love with sushi but the recommended roll hit the spot, and the new pork belly dish was phenomenal..You can tell they put a lot of love and soul into their dishes.But most importantly Heather's warm, friendly personality and hospitality made the visit so much more special! I loved chatting with her, she was so kind and patient with any questions even close to closing time. She would have me coming back to visit and dine again and again.This was my favorite restaurant visit of my trip on the island!
John G.
1683386321
We went here for dinner of 5/5 for our anniversary dinner which is 5/5. Our server Chris was excellent - had a great command of the food and drinks. My wife had a margarita and I had the drink among giants - always leery in Florid of something that's supposed to be " old fashioned" but it was better than average - just a little sweet.Wife had a caesar salad with anchovies on the side. More than she wanted so I got taste - we both thought it was very good. She couldn't finish the little guys. She then had a volcano sushi roll which is Chilean seabass - large serving. I had the roasted duck breast - lots of deliciousness.It's expensive but you usually get what you pay for.
Just.G. D.
1683314734
If you are looking for a delicious meal, great atmosphere and excellent staff look no further than here! It was so good and worth every cent we went back the next night for dinner as well.The first evening we were there our server Chantel was very knowledgeable, any questions we asked about an ingredient or a suggestion she was on point, no saying I'll be right back I need to ask someone else. She was very attentive and kind as well. Our Grouper Chowder and Sushi Rolls, Montego Bay Roll and the Snake River Roll were delectable. On our second evening there our server was Chris, another excellent server, who we could tell took pride in his job. He was quick, accurate and also attentive and gave great suggestions. Once again the food was divine, choosing the Prime Filet Mignon Topped with two jumbo shrimp and Grouper special. Their selection of drinks are unique and the outdoor dining is inviting and comfortable. Beautiful views of Lemon Bay. We can not wait to have another vacation on Manasota Key, mainly because we can't wait to come back and feast again at Magnolias on the Bay! Thank You!
Alyse W.
1683239879
Super cute atmosphere and unique menu! The staff is wonderful and the food is just as great. Their drinks were done very well- we tried the beekeepers cocktail and the key lime martini (both 10/10). The sushi rolls are much larger than expected. Overall a nice spot for fine dining in the area!
Elissah Z.
1683160220
Joey G is amazing!! Great service and food. 10/10 recommend 🙌
Belinda Brainerd C.
1682946120
Third visit here and always a great experience
Daniel W.
1682563688
BEST food, drinks and service in town.
James N.
1681685691
Out of this world!!! Nothing bad on the menu!!!
Courtney P.
1681591063
We just had our wedding there and had the most perfect experience. We were originally booked at Waverly but with the hurricane damage, canceled due to being unsure of when repairs would actually be finished. We were going to cancel our wedding completely until my parents had visited to help clean up my grandparent’s place after the hurricane. They had rave reviews about Magnolia’s and the beautiful setting and amazing food. They asked the manager if they hosted weddings, and they said not yet but we’re starting to get into it. We contacted them, decided to take our chances and book with them and it was the best decision we ever could have made. Keith handled everything so well. Everything from the amazing food, to the friendly serving staff, and set up and organization of everything was absolutely perfect. Every guest has complimented how impressed they were with the whole place. We highly recommend Magnolia’s (especially for a wedding venue, though currently they are only available for weddings on Sundays and Mondays). You won’t regret it! And may I say again how amazing the food is?? (Photos by Myra Coxey)
Joseph F. V.
1681489303
What can I say it was absolutely delicious we ordered the coconut shrimp sushi as an appetizer the waiter dropped us off some homemade garlic butter biscuits. It was the best sushi ever had... I had the lobster scallops and shrimp and roasted potatoes it was delicious.The wife had roasted duck, and she said it was delicious. Our Guest had the scallops in a bed of lemon risotto and asparagus. She also said it was very good... The outdoor atmosphere was beautiful. Service was outstanding. We will definitely be back... Oh, and by the way, if you're in Inglewood Nov thro May, there's a good 5 Star Barber at Perin's Barber Shop... Ask for Joe V or he gos by the name of 5 Star..
Jennifer R.
1681416668
We went there for my birthday dinner. New sushi menu is outstanding. We also loved the fish of the day. Everything was fantastic.
Lori S.
1681413202
Everything was absolutely amazing!!!!!! From the tuna appetizer, to all of our dinners of the Filet to the Salmon, the dessert and the server!!!! Destiny...
Ash C.
1681318520
Unbelievable, one of the best restaurants we've ever been to in a long time. It's not cheap but definitely worth it. I had the Poke bowl, sashimi & stuffed jalapenos all amazing but the bread was unreal. Make sure to make reservations
Pat B.
1681210815
This visit we had Grouper, Steak and Shrimp in Teriyaki Sauce and Scallops. All were excellent as our past visits.
Melissa H.
1681133331
Amazing food and drinks. The sushi was a whole other level and a great surprise appetizer. We had a party of 12 people and everyone was super impressed with the quality of service and taste. Its worth every penny and the staff is always friendly. Request Joey G as your server, he was FABULOUS and fun with a great sense of humor.
Kim Wright, PA, R.
1680642135
Peaceful spot on Lemon Bay. Consistently delicious food, good service and we enjoy and admire the ambiance amidst the location.
Debbie S.
1680400771
Everything was exceptional
Harold S.
1680284963
Celebrated our wedding at Magnolia’s. We were treated like honored guests. Had a special table set up away from everyone else and decorated beautifully for us to dine quietly. Food was delicious and presented beautifully. Can’t praise the server enough, she was so friendly, courteous and did an amazing job making sure our evening was special. All the staff we encountered were polite and accommodating. The view was beautiful. A hidden gem for sure.
Sara H.
1680127541
My Boyfriend Cody Barnes who work here at Magnolias an amazing cook made me a delicious and beautiful volcano sushi roll 😋
Sara H.
1680127305
My Boyfriend Cody Barnes who works here an amazing cook made me a delicious and beautiful volcano sushi roll 😋
Jessica B.
1680123625
Beautiful place. Great food.
Island S.
1680050343
Always, and in all ways... exceeds expectations!I'm a local and this is overwhelmingly positioned as the best dining experience to be had near Englewood and or Manasota Key!!
Nicholas ..
1679790395
This place is a gem. Warm, welcoming, incredible atmosphere. The staff is incredible and so meticulously trained to enhance your dining experience. Eta, our waitress was amazing.The food is prepared with attention to detail that competes or rivals any 5 star dining in the area, including Sarasota. Fresh, perfectly seasoned, and flavors that leave you longing for more.This is fine dining, with a casual atmosphere. The sushi is precisely prepared.We will be back!!! Thank you for an amazing evening.
Kimberly P.
1679694481
Adorable little place in Englewood, FL by the beach, that backs up to the bay. Remodeled home and backyard transformed into a chic place to eat with an exceptional menu. Reservations highly recommended.
Mary M.
1678835430
Super cute restaurant. Very modern and the food was amazing! Ordered sushi and the roll was SO GOOD, unique and huge!
Kristan Q.
1678633767
We had an absolutely amazing dinner last night at our favorite place Magnolias On The Bay! 🥂☀️Crab cakes 🦀 pan seared Mahi Mahi 🐠 and a Magolias Volcano Roll! Also, their Smoked Whiskey Ice Ball drink is definitely the best drink I've ever had!!The service was beyond exceptional! Our servers name was Daniel. He was very informative about the menu and specials for the day!
Sue S.
1678238623
Food is amazing...cocktails are so pricey, atmosphere is fabulous.
Todd F.
1678235136
Always perfect there. Beautiful place. Go there just go there.
Richard T.
1678125210
Great setting on the bay. Wonderful food & drinks. A little pricey but well worth it.
Clarke T.
1677812300
This is a favorite of ours, both our married kids and most guests that visit the area. Excellent food and great service. A place to go for a special night if you feel need to splurge.
Florida Aerial Pics Drone P.
1677012966
Amazingly good food. Never disappointed
Lynn G.
1677006168
Love..love..love this place. Food is wonderful, atmosphere fantastic...staff is excellent. Highly recommend!!
Zach M.
1676993882
The Bloody Bull was one of the best bloody mary's I've ever had. The Key Lime pie is better than anything I had while actually in the Keys. Food was great, service was wonderful, experience was exceptional!
LaVerne M.
1676511835
This place is amazing and fun. Great food and drinks
Walter P.
1676425822
Wonderful place, both indoor & outdoor seating with a nice view of the bay. Food is excellent, definitely a professional chef at work in the kitchen. Tasty little Peruvian red peppers decorate most dishes, a new one for me. Expect to spend a little more and get a little more at Magnolias, one of the few truly gourmet restaurants in the area.
KARLO
1676253189
AMAZING FOOD AND SERVICE!!! I LOVE THIS PLACE!!! AMAZING CHEFS!!!
Richard D.
1676160030
Wonderful bartender in Brian. Great sushi roll!
Karen Mills D.
1675907088
Delicious food and lovely waterfront dining. Would definitely recommend❣️
